The push for independence is turning off Scots business – Financial Times
/in Economic Matters, Financial Times /by sm_adminScots business has not been wholly opposed to secession from the UK. Large figures in a relatively small world, such as Sir Brian Souter, the bus and train entrepreneur, and Tony Banks, developer of a large care home business, have been enthusiasts for the cause. But most business people have been sceptical, though quietly so.
To take up arms against nationalism and, by opposing, hope to diminish it has been generally seen as ill-advised. Some are in retail businesses and feel a need to avoid giving offence. Others rely on government contracts. Those in the media can fear being thought biased. All these factors deter critics of independence from speaking out.
The few who do speak, tweet or post, talk of some harassment, as I have found in conversations — usually anonymous, at their request — with many business people. One forceful tweeter against the Scottish National party, who also asked to remain anonymous, lost the board membership of a charity due to feared loss of government support. Another instanced a friend who said open opposition would force him to fire 50 workers, as loss of government work would follow.
Still another, a financier with a large farm, told me he was constantly investigated by various authorities, while a nationalist neighbour’s farm attracted no attention. If true, these episodes are enough to discourage most people from further complaint. They are also grossly undemocratic.
Business scepticism is based largely on the economic case against secession. As the May 6 election for Scotland’s parliament approaches, a raft of reports are warning of a period of austerity, inflicted not by Westminster — a constant theme in SNP rhetoric — but by an independent Scottish government.
The party’s present economic programme is based on work by the SNP-funded Sustainable Growth Commission, published in 2018. It advises retaining sterling as Scotland’s currency for up to a decade after independence, a policy much disliked by party activists. It would mean Scotland had a currency over which it had no control — and thus could not, as it might wish to, devalue.
The independent state would lose subsidies from the UK Treasury amounting to £1,633 a year per person, according to a Financial Times analysis. Annual tax rises or spending cuts equivalent to £1,765 per person would be needed to reduce a budget deficit, currently running at almost 10 per cent of annual economic output, to the EU’s 3 per cent ceiling.
Another report, from the Institute for Government, estimated that unpicking Scotland’s 1707 union with England and negotiating EU membership could take a decade. A hard border between Scotland and the rest of the UK, which takes around 60 per cent of Scottish exports, would be “the inevitable result” of Scottish EU membership, the report said.
Many business people believe Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland’s first minister, is ill-disposed to business. One entrepreneur who set out to her the economic downsides of secession got the reply: “I am a conviction politician.” The pursuit of independence trumps all else.
This scorn makes business people angry. They think they are cast as Scots Scrooges, indifferent to poverty and inequality. Jim McColl, founder and chief executive of Clyde Blowers Capital, an engineering and investment group, says: “There’s a feeling that people who have businesses don’t want social programmes. Business people do want these — they’re all for levelling up. But you can’t fund all the social programmes without business thriving.”
The gulf between business and pro-independence politicians is arguably wider than ever. But Sturgeon is right: “conviction politicians” who seek fundamental constitutional change must possess a rare belief in self, party and people. Such a belief must shrug off ordinary people’s daily concerns.
Sturgeon’s steely determination has been strengthened by an inquiry that cleared her of misleading the Scottish parliament. Yet qualms in her party persist. In a leaked video of briefings given by two SNP ministers to activists, one conceded that the currency issue could hobble a post-independence government. The other told his audience not to be pulled into a discussion on currency, but state that the SNP believed in keeping sterling and move on.
Her latest challenge is from her one-time mentor, now embittered opponent Alex Salmond, first minister from 2007 to 2014. He portrays his new Alba party as a way of increasing support for nationalism, but it may hurt the SNP’s chances of winning an outright majority in the Scottish parliament.
Business people are rarely political zealots. Scots in business, inventors, economists and philosophers have changed the world — but that was mainly in the 18th and 19th centuries, when Britain and its empire, in which Scots were hyperactive, were growing strongly. Now, most find the grind of maintaining and developing complex companies enough of a day’s hard work.
In Walter Scott’s novel Rob Roy (1817), a Glasgow merchant, Baillie Nicol Jarvie, scornful of opponents of the union with England, says “it’s an ill wind blaws naebody gude . . . what was ever like to gar [make] us flourish like the sugar and tobacco trade? Will onybody tell me that, and grumble at the treaty that opened us a road west-awa’ yonder?”
It would be a rare Glasgow merchant who spoke in these terms today, not least because sugar and tobacco were products of slave labour. But many would quietly admit that the union opened Scotland up, and fear that independence, coupled with Brexit, would to some degree close them off from their large and lucrative market to the south.
Categories
- Aberdeen Evening Express
- Alba
- Alex Salmond
- Alex Salmond Inquiry
- Alister Jack
- Allan Sutherland
- Allan Thompson
- Articles
- BBC
- Bloomberg
- Brian Monteith
- CAPx
- Census 2022
- Clarity Act
- Conservative
- Conservative Post
- COP26
- Country Squire
- Covid inquiry
- Covid-19
- Daily Business
- Daily Express
- Daily Mail
- Daily Record
- David Bone
- Defence Matters
- Dennis Grattan
- Douglas Cowe
- Drugs
- Economic Matters
- Edinburgh Evening News
- Edinburgh Live
- Edinburgh Matters
- Education Matters
- Election 2021
- Environment Matters
- Ferguson Marine
- Financial Times
- FutureScot
- GB news
- Gerald Edwards
- Glasgow Evening Times
- Glasgow Live
- Glasgow Matters
- Glasgpw Live
- Gordon Brown
- gov.uk
- Health Matters
- Holyrood Magazine
- Huffington Post
- Ian Balloch
- Ian Blackford
- Indyref 2
- inews
- Insider.co.uk
- Jane Lax
- Jenny Gilruth
- Jill Stephenson
- John Swinney
- Kate Forbes
- Letters
- Local elections 2022
- Local Matters
- Lorna Slater
- Mark Openshaw
- Media
- Morning Star
- MSN
- National Care Service
- NHS Scotland
- NHS Scotland
- Nicola Sturgeon
- North East Matters
- Notes on Nationalism
- Opinion
- orderorder.com
- Pensions
- Political Parties
- Politics Matters
- politics.co.uk
- Prestwick Airport
- Regina Erich
- Richard Allison
- Richard Marsh
- Rishi Sunak
- Robert Scott
- Ruth Davidson
- Satire
- Scotland Matters
- Scotland Under the SNP
- Scottish Conservatives
- Scottish devolution
- Scottish Government
- Scottish Greens
- Scottish Independence
- Scottish Labour
- Shirley-Anne Somerville
- Sky News
- SNP
- Some Good News
- Stephendaisley.com
- STV News
- The Critic
- The Ferret
- The Grocer
- The Guardian
- The Independent
- The New European
- The New Statesman
- The Northern Scot
- The Scotsman
- The Spectator
- The Sun
- The Sunday Post
- The Telegraph
- The Times
- The West Coast Matters
- ThinkScotland
- Transport Matters
- Trident
- UK Defence Journal
- Uncategorised
- United Kingdom
- Unity Matters
- Victor Clements
- wecan.scot
- Weekly Update
- William Ballantine
- Yahoo News
Pages
- ‘Education Not Separation, Tactical Vote Swinney Out’ by Scotland Matters
- ‘Education not Separation’ billboard
- ‘Inverclyde Hospital Cuts’ Billboard by Scotland Matters
- ‘Job Creation Not Separation’ billboard
- ‘Nothing Super About This Majority Puppet Show’ Billboard by Scotland Matters
- ‘School for Scandal’ Billboard by Scotland Matters
- ‘Titanic Failures’ Billboard by Scotland Matters
- ‘Vaccination Not Separation’ billboard
- #ResignSturgeon campaign launches across Scotland
- 500K pro-uk voters open to tactical voting to beat SNP
- 93% of NO voters would vote tactically
- Aberdeenshire Council – Mid-Formartine by election Thursday, 19th August 2019 – Tactical vote the SNP out!
- About us
- Articles
- Billboards
- Billboards
- Blogs
- Books
- Broadcast Media
- Checkpoint McCharlie
- Contact
- Contacts – local press
- Contacts – national press
- COPout26
- Defence Matters
- Donate
- donotvoteSNP – Local Elections 2022
- Download our Billboards
- Economy Matters
- Education Matters
- Environment Matters
- Events
- Evidence to back up our advert
- Falkirk South by-election, Thursday, 14th of October 2021 – Tactical vote the SNP out!
- Footer
- Health Matters
- Help us beat the SNP. Share our campaign posters.
- Holyrood 2021
- Holyrood 2021 Campaign
- Home
- How to vote in the Scottish local election 2022
- How to…
- Inaugural Meeting
- Job Creation Not Separation Billboard in Glasgow
- Job Creation Not Seperation
- Letters -30/06/22
- Letters to the Scottish Press
- MetZero
- More Advert Evidence
- News
- Other Campaign Groups
- Our Campaign – Local Elections 2022
- Our COP26 Advans
- Pensions
- Political Parties
- Politics Matters
- Press Contacts
- Press Release
- Press release – Aberdeen Advans
- Previous Events
- Resources and Links
- Sample Page
- ScotFail – “I don’t drive the trains”
- Scotland Matters Advan Tour: Local Elections 2022.
- Scotland Matters COP26 Campaign
- Scotland Matters COP26 Press release: SNP “MET ZERO“ renewable jobs targets
- Scotland Matters Election Advan Tour
- Scotland Matters Media Release: Who put the lights out?
- Scottish local election 2022: £100 million from education
- Scottish local election 2022: A meme share a day makes the SNP go away
- Scottish local election 2022: Angry at council tax rises and cuts?
- Scottish local election 2022: block the SNP and green mini-me
- Scottish local election 2022: chauffeur driven
- Scottish local election 2022: Fed up with ferry fiasco?
- Scottish local election 2022: Kick the SNP in the ballot box
- Scottish local election 2022: libaries closed
- Scottish local election 2022: Likes are nice but shares are better
- Scottish local election 2022: Pot holes have increased 500% under the SNP
- Scottish local election 2022: Protest Vote
- Scottish local election 2022: send a message
- Scottish local election 2022: Send Sturgeon a message – protest vote
- Scottish local election 2022: SNP have spent £3 million on social media
- Scottish Newspapers
- Second Billboard Calling for Voters to Back Anas Sarwar Revealed
- Selected Articles
- SNP Fails
- SNP Fails – Edinburgh Matters
- SNP Fails – Glasgow Matters
- SNP Fails – The North-East Matters
- SNP Fails – The West Coast Matters
- SNP: Stronger for Non-Scottish Shipyards
- Social Media
- South Ayrshire
- Steering Committee
- Sturgeon Goes to Washington
- subscribe to our newsletter
- Tactical Voting – posters for download
- The Scotland Matters COP26 campaign – What We Did
- The SNP: 14 years of broken Promises, Incompetence, scandal, division and decline.
- The Times newspaper apologises to Scotland Matters
- Think Tanks
- Transport Matters
- Unity Matters
- University Societies
- Videos
- Westminster advan press release
- What is the worst failure of the SNP in your local area? – Tell us below
- Where’s The SNP Promised 130,000 Green Jobs?
Categories
- Aberdeen Evening Express
- Alba
- Alex Salmond
- Alex Salmond Inquiry
- Alister Jack
- Allan Sutherland
- Allan Thompson
- Articles
- BBC
- Bloomberg
- Brian Monteith
- CAPx
- Census 2022
- Clarity Act
- Conservative
- Conservative Post
- COP26
- Country Squire
- Covid inquiry
- Covid-19
- Daily Business
- Daily Express
- Daily Mail
- Daily Record
- David Bone
- Defence Matters
- Dennis Grattan
- Douglas Cowe
- Drugs
- Economic Matters
- Edinburgh Evening News
- Edinburgh Live
- Edinburgh Matters
- Education Matters
- Election 2021
- Environment Matters
- Ferguson Marine
- Financial Times
- FutureScot
- GB news
- Gerald Edwards
- Glasgow Evening Times
- Glasgow Live
- Glasgow Matters
- Glasgpw Live
- Gordon Brown
- gov.uk
- Health Matters
- Holyrood Magazine
- Huffington Post
- Ian Balloch
- Ian Blackford
- Indyref 2
- inews
- Insider.co.uk
- Jane Lax
- Jenny Gilruth
- Jill Stephenson
- John Swinney
- Kate Forbes
- Letters
- Local elections 2022
- Local Matters
- Lorna Slater
- Mark Openshaw
- Media
- Morning Star
- MSN
- National Care Service
- NHS Scotland
- NHS Scotland
- Nicola Sturgeon
- North East Matters
- Notes on Nationalism
- Opinion
- orderorder.com
- Pensions
- Political Parties
- Politics Matters
- politics.co.uk
- Prestwick Airport
- Regina Erich
- Richard Allison
- Richard Marsh
- Rishi Sunak
- Robert Scott
- Ruth Davidson
- Satire
- Scotland Matters
- Scotland Under the SNP
- Scottish Conservatives
- Scottish devolution
- Scottish Government
- Scottish Greens
- Scottish Independence
- Scottish Labour
- Shirley-Anne Somerville
- Sky News
- SNP
- Some Good News
- Stephendaisley.com
- STV News
- The Critic
- The Ferret
- The Grocer
- The Guardian
- The Independent
- The New European
- The New Statesman
- The Northern Scot
- The Scotsman
- The Spectator
- The Sun
- The Sunday Post
- The Telegraph
- The Times
- The West Coast Matters
- ThinkScotland
- Transport Matters
- Trident
- UK Defence Journal
- Uncategorised
- United Kingdom
- Unity Matters
- Victor Clements
- wecan.scot
- Weekly Update
- William Ballantine
- Yahoo News